|Carol Page Tilson (#46543875)|
| || member for 12 years, 6 months, 26 days|
| [Add to MyFriends]|
|Bio and Links|
As a former newspaper reporter/photographer, high school journalism teacher, old-fashioned genealogical researcher and long-time Find A Grave member, I believe the best memorial is correct, as complete as possible and linked to parents, spouse and children. It should memorialize a person, not just a name.|
Most of my memorials are for my own or my husband's ancestors and collateral kin, some close relatives, some distant, with some in-laws.
However, not all have been created by relatives or those who consider it a service to photograph markers, recording burials in their home locales. The majority, with minimal content, have been submitted by others whose sources and motives vary.
I do take issue with those who insist Find A Grave is strictly a "graves registry." While that may have been the case in the beginning, the site has evolved over the years with maiden name, parental/spousal link and other options added. To deny F-A-G has a genealogical purpose is folly, especially since it's now owned by Ancestry.com.
Fair warning: Find A Grave memorials are not primary documentation. The main problem is that "engraved in stone" does not necessarily mean it's true. Names and dates on grave markers are often wrong; everything on a death certificate or what's in an obit isn't always true.
Info on the dead is provided by the living based on what they know, think they know, what's written in the Family Bible or what they once were told. Unfortunately, people make mistakes.
Whether or not a memorial is factual depends on everyone from whoever decided what would be inscribed on a marker and the stone cutter, to whoever kept cemetery records and/or "read" the marker or typed up the online burial list.
I make no claim of being perfect [my dadgum mouse definitely has a problem with drop-down option lists]. As a family researcher, I want to know if I've done something stupid or wrong.
In bygone days, I asked for proof from those requesting changes. With the increasingly widespread acceptance of F-A-G's "do-it-yourself" edit process, I've had to toss in the towel and go with the flow. However, for me, making major changes in data without evidence is counter-productive and distasteful. I'd appreciate knowing the source for any such alteration.
Unfortunately, not all folks asking for changes are researchers. Thus, this "convenient" edit option cannot help but affect the overall credibility of the site.
Any edits which disagree with vital record evidence will be declined. And if I can't contact a person to ask for source of info, his/her edit will not be accepted. If you opt to post under an anonymous screen name and not take messages, don't even waste your time.
Use the final option on the edit menu if you want a more specific explanation for a "decline" or would like evidence for one of my suggestions [I often send a vital record or obit anyway].
I'll gladly transfer a memorial to any researcher more closely connected to the individual than I -- fourth cousin beats fifth cousin twice removed. I'd especially like to reunite in-laws whom I've not researched in-depth with their direct kin. Please, just write and ask.
When it comes to Find A Grave, I consider family and FACTS more important than FAQs.
4 Jan 2015
|Find A Grave Friends|
Alice , J.K.Erickson, Janet Muff, Jen Snoots, John Arsenault, Julie Nathanson, Kay Cynova, l'Hexagone, Linda Berney, Marilyn Solari, Michael Buye, Mojo Warren, mommycita, Robert Alexande..., Rose Wenstrom, Sandra Franklin, Sharon Turner
|Messages left for Carol Page Tils... (116)||[Leave Message]|
|Linda Berney||RE: Peter Graae|
Have you seen her actual obit? It appears that the person who extracted it also saw the wrong spelling on it. Very strange!
|Kathy and Jim Schutt||RE: Mary Ann Colvin Update|
I have to add an interesting note. I do have the death certificate for Mary Ann "Polly" Fall. It was Mary Ann Von Schassen. Whoever gave the information said her mother was Mary Howland. Which would have been her grandmother.
|Kathy and Jim Schutt||RE: Mary Ann Colvin Update|
Thanks so much for the info. It looks like 1889 to me but it is very hard to tell. I am on ancestry and half of the family connections say 1889 and the other half 1899. I had Oakland county check 1889 but it wasn't there. I have sent to the state for 1889. It may be a wild goose chase :) Anyway, thanks for the help and I will keep you posted. On ancestry no one shows that she remarried but that doesn't mean a lot.
Still searching for information on the elusive Cliford, but I did edit DOD as per your suggestion.
|Kathy and Jim Schutt||Mary Ann Colvin|
I have noticed with interest that you have listed Antipass Colvin and Mary Howland as Mary Ann's parents on the Find A Grave memorial. This is new information to me and much appreciated. I am going to send to Oakland for her death certificate and am hoping that it also lists her parents. If that were listed I might have proof to the DAR that my 5th great-grandfather Levi Colvin was my ancestor. I see he fought in the American Revolutionary War. I have proof that Jeremiah was Levi's son but need to connect Antipass to him and Mary Ann to Antipass.
Thank you very much,
|James Bellert||RE: Pingry|
I'm happy to add/correct information from the index information you send. If you notice I've made any mistakes in making changes/additions, please don't hesitate to let me know.
All the best,
|John Quiring||RE: Hartquest at Richland|
Hi. There was a small infant marker (no name that I could see) near the Harquest markers. Were there some deaths of infants born to Abraham and Antoinette? I took a couple of photos.
(Love the dog in your profile.) John Q
|James Bellert||LILLIAN P. GORHAM|
Thank you for the biographical information. I've added it to the memorial with a credit to you and linked her parents' memorials to hers.
Happy New Year!
|John Quiring||Hartquest at Richland|
Hi. I posted several pictures of the Ab. Hartquest family at the Richland Cemetery. The long shadows and the position of the sun was not best for some angles. Also I did not find a marker for William. on his memorial page I posted a picture of the whole family plot with the three big stones and the smaller father/mother stones. If you need something deleted or retaken let me know. I don't make it out Richland much but would be willing to do something more when I do.
|Treva Poe||Moore 10646084|
Thank you for the Moore edits. Appreciate your dedication to this site.
|[View all messages...]|
Privacy Statement and Terms of Service